18 Comments

Chickadee Abundance in Response to Human Presence at the Morgan Arboretum

Appearance and Identification:

Black-capped Chickadees (Poecile atricapillus) are well-known songbirds, loved by everyone due to their adorable appearance and curiosity. They have a distinctive black cap and bib, contrasting with their white cheeks. Their sides are buff colored and the feathers of the wings and the tail are gray with paler edges. They molt every year in late summer, after their breeding season. Visually, it is extremely difficult to identify the sex and age of the chickadees since there are no distinctive features differentiating them. They have an average length of 5 ¼ inches with a wingspan from 6 to 8 inches (5). Black-capped Chickadees use a variety of distinctive calls (fee-bee, chick-a-dee, seet), depending on their intentions (alarms, courtships, etc.) and certain acoustic features in the “fee” part of a call allows us to distinguish between male and female calls (2).

The characteristic black cap and bib make Black-capped Chickadees easy to identify

The characteristic black cap and bib make Black-capped Chickadees easy to identify

Nesting:

The most common place for Black-capped Chickadees to nest is inside cavities of rotten trees dug by them or abandoned by woodpeckers or other birds. When digging their own nest hole, they will scatter the wood chips away from the site to avoid attracting predators. The female is the one in charge of building the nest and uses rabbit fur or soft plant fibers for cushioning (5). She will then lay one egg per day until there are about 6 to 8 eggs. The young hatch after 13 to 14 days and will leave the nest 16 to 17 days after hatching (1).

Distribution:

Black-capped Chickadees are widely distributed throughout North America, being found just below the Arctic all the way to the mid United-States stretching from the Pacific to the Atlantic coast (5). Due to this, the birds make use of many different habitats such as mixed and deciduous woods, thickets, and willow groves. Given suitable nesting areas, they can even be found in urban areas (1). The Black-capped Chickadees are non-migratory birds due their weak flight (5). Despite their weak flight, every few years when there is a large increase in population immature chickadees will fly south for the winter and return north in the fall in a phenomenon known as “irruption”(5).

 Food preference:

Black-capped Chickadees are omnivorous birds whose diet includes insects, berries, and seeds (1). As they do not migrate, the exact content of what they eat varies depending on seasonal availability. Since feeders provide an easy source of food, it is common to see them flock to feeders, but they won’t stay on the feeder long. Chickadees seldom eat on the spot and instead either fly to safety to eat or store their food (called caching) (5). The seeds are stored in various locations to prevent drastic losses if another bird was to find a cache and chickadees have demonstrated an amazing ability to recall these locations (3,5). If the chickadees decide to eat the seeds rather than cache them for later, they often fly away with a seed to a covered branch before holding it with their feet and pecking at it.

video: To eat, Black-capped Chickadees hold the seed with their feet and peck at it with their beak until it breaks open. You can also hear the characteristic “chicka-dee-dee” call they make, where the number of “dees” in the call increases when they feel threatened

Behaviours:

Despite their tendency to travel in noisy parties, the friendly Black-capped Chickadee is very choosy about when and with whom it will eat. Upon observing chickadees at a bird feeder, we noticed that they don’t like feeding at the same time as other birds, whether of their own or another species. They patiently wait until one bird has flown away before taking their turn. The weather also influences chickadee’s foraging; on cold, windy days they forage lower to the ground in more dense foliage to block the wind (5).

Video: Chickadees often wait their turn at feeders. It is rare to see two birds, of the same or different species, on the same side of the feeder at the same time. (other bird featured: White-Breasted Nuthatch)

An interesting study done on anti-predator behaviour in Black-capped Chickadees showed that the birds will trade off foraging for safety. After being exposed to a simulated predator, fewer birds visit the food patch and they take longer to come out of hiding to get more food, especially when the patch is further away from their refuge (6). It’s possible to tell when a chickadee is in peril simply by noting the amount of “dees” in their famous “chick-a-dee” call. The more “dees” heard the higher level of threat present (4). It turns out that higher ranked chickadees are leaner than lower ranked individuals, and therefore are more manoeuvrable in the face of predators. That’s not their only advantage; females will select males of higher rank to mate with before considering their subordinates (3). Chickadees become more quiet and inconspicuous during their summer mating season, which is very different from the behaviour we see in the fall (5).

 

Our Project:

Their non-migratory way of life and stable presence at the Morgan Arboretum makes Black-capped Chickadees the perfect study species for our research. The ease with which they adapt to humans was also key in helping us develop our research question: Does human presence and activity in certain areas of the Morgan Arboretum influence Black-capped Chickadee abundance and behaviour?

With this question guiding us, we used visual and auditory cues to survey six sites in the Morgan Arboretum. The six sites included three sites with lots of human activity off a hiking trail used year round, and the other three were off a snowshoe trail with very little human activity this time of year. Auditory cues were relied on most, and the spacing and direction of calls were used to distinguish if we were hearing one or multiple individuals. If the calls were spaced out and from different directions, they were counted as coming from different individuals, whereas calls that were less spaced and from the same area were counted as one individual. To survey the sites, we split into two groups of two and took different routes in order to obtain more observations of the sites at different times. Once we arrived at a site, we waited five minutes before recording observations so the area was less disturbed. After the five minutes, we recorded abundances as well as behaviours for fifteen minutes. From our three days of data collection we noticed that chickadees do seem to be more abundant in the high human activity sites.

References:

(1) Foote, J.R; Mennill, D.J; Ratcliffe, L.M; Smith, S.M. 2010. Black-capped Chickadee (Poecile atricapillus), The Birds of North America Online (A. Poole, Ed.). Ithaca: Cornell Lab of Ornithology; [cited 2015 Oct 27]. Retrieved from the Birds of North America Online: http://bna.birds.cornell.edu/bna/species/039 doi:10.2173/bna.39

(2) Hahn, A.H; Hoang, J; McMillan, N; Campbell, N; Congdon, J; Sturdy, C.B. 2015. Biological salience influences performance and acoustic mechanisms for the discrimination of male and female songs. Animal Behaviour, 104, 213-228.

(3) Otter, K.A. 2007. Ecology and Behaviour of Chickadees and Titmice: an integrated approach. New York: Oxford University Press.

(4) Schwarz, J; Greene, E; Davis, K. 2005. Chickadees’ alarm-calls carry information about size, threat of predator. University of Washington.

(5) Smith, S.M. 1997. Wild bird guides: Black-capped Chickadee. 1st edn. Hong-Kong: Stackpole Books.

(6) Turney, S; Godin, J.G.J. 2014. To forage or hide? Threat-sensitive foraging behaviour in wild, non-reproductive passerine birds. Current Zoology, 60, 719-728.

Advertisements

18 comments on “Chickadee Abundance in Response to Human Presence at the Morgan Arboretum

  1. Thanks for the post – what a great project. Chickadees are lovely birds – small but full of energy and personality. You mention and show the nuthatch – what other birds did you observe during your study, and did you record any direct interactions among the different birds and chickadees? I’m curious about the how much Chickadee behaviour varies depending on the species it encounters.

    • Once we saw a woodpecker perched on the feeder before it flew away to a nearby tree, and the chickadees were more vocal than they normally were. The chickadees also were nowhere near the feeder when the woodpecker was on it. There was also what we believed to be a sparrow present during a data collection session, but I don’t recall any different behaviors from the chickadees then; they were not much more vocal and they didn’t shy away from going to the feeder. Those were the only two species we saw, but we did hear a lot of crows one day and the chickadees were very vocal and had a lot of “dees” in their “chicka-dee-dee” call.

    • Also thank you for your comment and interest!

  2. Great blog post! It sounds like an interesting project. Did you ever see humans feeding the chickadees? If so, do you think this could account for the higher abundance of chickadees at the high human activity sites?

    • Great question! We didn`t personally see anyone feeding them but the site with the feeder is well known as a place where chickadees will eat out of people`s hands. We recorded the highest abundances at the feeder which could be due to the presence of easy to access food.

  3. Projet intéressant et très instructif: je vais être plus attentive aux chants et au comportement des mésanges que je vois près des mangeoires!

  4. Why do you think chickadees are more abundant in areas of the arboretum used by humans? Do they usually find more food near humans outside of the arboretum (e.g., feeders) so they are attracted to humans in general? Or is there more food in the arboretum areas used by humans, even when humans are not present?

    • From what we’ve seen it seems to be the presence of food provided by humans that attracts chickadees to those areas. The site that had the feeder typically had the highest abundances of all of our sites, and was also the site where we saw the chickadees most and didn’t have to rely solely on auditory cues to identify them. Chickadees are very good at adapting to humans presence and exploiting easy food sources that we introduce such as feeders.

  5. My question is regarding ranking. I just wonder how does one know a bird is higher ranked? Also is there ranking with both genders? Beyond mating preference displayed by females for higher ranked leaner males, do higher ranked individuals eat first at the feeders? If both genders indeed do have ranks, are the females leaner too? Thank you, though I have had some very interesting experiences with Chickadees over the years, I did not know quite a bit of the information you noted, nests lined with rabbit fur!! Wonderful!! Thank you!

    • While we did find many literature that indicate a hierarchical system within a flock of chickadees, it was not something we explicitly tried to look out for during our data gathering. The sources seem to agree that males exhibit dominance towards females and towards each other based on age. There was not exactly a proper method to identify a Chickadee’s rank when it came to the feeder, but we did notice that some would defer to other individuals despite having landed first. This may be an indication that there is a social status dictating pecking order.
      We hope this helped and thank you for your time!

  6. thank you Avian Tweets, how did the sources conclude that dominance appears to be based on age, were the birds banded and is this how age was determined?

    • One study banded birds at installed feeders at the end of the breeding season, after the young had time to mature. They then replaced the feeders with something called a dominance board (a modified feeder). This allowed them to observe interactions between individuals as the birds tried to access the food while competing with each other.
      You can read more about it in the study called “Between-year Survival and Rank Transitions in Male Black-Capped Chickadees (Poecile atricapillus): A Multistate Modeling Approach” conducted by Schubert et al. (2008).
      We hope this helped!

  7. Yes, thank you for this response and for referring me to the study by Schubert et al, I am indeed learning a great deal!! Thank you for the “dominance board” note above, I of course was very curious about what this item was exactly so, I googled the term and this then led me to the article by Maki Sumitani May 2014 in the Journal of Young Investigators, “Feeding effects on feeding black capped chickadees” – all so very interesting and totally fascinating to me. Thank you very much for your responses and for totally piquing my curiosity and inspiring me to look further at the behaviour of this feisty little creature I thought I knew!

    • It’s amazing how much there is to learn about them and there are probably still so many questions that have yet to be answered! Thank you so much for your comments and enthusiasm! We’re glad we were able to pique your interest and hope your fascination with chickadees continues.

  8. Do chickadees alarm call more in the presence of humans, even in those areas of the arboretum where they’ve been found to be more abundant in areas of greater human activity? i.e. do they still associate humans as a risk even though they’re willing to get close to them for an easier, constant food source?

    • From what we’ve learned, it seems as though it’s humans disturbing larger, predatory birds which causes them to be more alarmed, rather than the humans directly. Since they tend to associate humans with food, they’re not alarmed by our presence. Thank you for your question, hopefully that helps!

Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: